Michael Meets the Pollard Trade in Week 9 as Waivers Spend $570 and Dominic Rebuilds His Roster Again
The verdict. Dominic gets the best player in the deal and the insurance behind him, and Michael gets two starting backs for a backfield that had one. The odds say Dominic wins it: the trade alone moves his title chance from 23.1% to 25.1% and Michael's from 7.1% to 5.9%. For Michael it is a repair, not a collapse, because it fills a hole that was already costing him points.
Tuten was on the field Thursday night, so the condition on the deal was met. Here are both Week 9 lineups as Sleeper shows them, projected after the trade.
| SLOT | DOMINIC | PROJ | MICHAEL | PROJ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| QB | Brock Purdy (SF) | 26.39 | Trevor Lawrence (JAX) | 24.91 |
| RB | Kenneth Walker III (KC) | 21.99 | Josh Jacobs (GB) | 13.95 |
| RB | Bijan Robinson (ATL) | 23.05 | Bhayshul Tuten (JAX) | 13.40 |
| WR | Malik Nabers (NYG) | 15.72 | Antonio Williams (WAS) | 7.54 |
| WR | Ja'Marr Chase (CIN) | 19.70 | Chris Olave (NO) | 15.39 |
| TE | George Kittle (SF) | 15.19 | Tyler Warren (IND) | 13.24 |
| FLEX | Amon-Ra St. Brown (DET) | 20.33 | Rome Odunze (CHI) | 11.48 |
| FLEX | Matthew Golden (GB) | 14.89 | Isaiah Likely (NYG) | 11.46 |
| K | Spencer Shrader (IND) | 8.19 | Tyler Bass (BUF) | 8.11 |
| DEF | Chiefs (KC) | 9.27 | Bears (CHI) | 8.45 |
| TOTAL | 174.72 | 127.93 |
Dominic's bench: Emmett Johnson (KC) 6.43, Jonah Coleman (DEN) 14.38, Jalen Coker (CAR) 13.96, B. Robinson Jr. (ATL) 6.02, Tyjae Spears (TEN) and Germie Bernard (PIT) on bye; James Conner and Alec Pierce on IR. Michael's bench: Xavier Worthy (KC) 10.29, Dylan Sampson (CLE) 8.65, Zonovan Knight (ARI) 5.10, Brian Thomas Jr. (JAX) 3.59, A.J. Brown (NE) and DeVonta Smith (PHI), both questionable; Jeremiyah Love and David Montgomery on IR.
Why it makes sense for Dominic
It fixes the one slot that was behind the rest. Purdy (26.39), Bijan Robinson (23.05), Walker's new spot (21.99), St. Brown (20.33) and Chase (19.70) are his five highest projections. The second running back slot was Jacobs at 13.95, so swapping in Walker is worth +8.04 in the only starting spot with room to move.
Walker is the best player in the deal. FantasyPros logs 410 rushing yards and four rushing touchdowns for him in four games (Weeks 4, 6, 7 and 8). Of those, 305 yards and all four touchdowns came in two games, 177 and 128 yards with two touchdowns each. He had 25 touches in Kansas City's Week 8 loss at Denver, so the volume is real. The risk is the other two games, 36 and 69 rushing yards, and Dominic is betting the first two show the true role.
Johnson is the insurance. He had five catches for 128 yards and a touchdown in Week 8 after one or two catches in each earlier game FantasyPros logs. He costs a bench spot (6.43 projected) and covers the one injury that would break Dominic's backfield.
The calendar helps. Kansas City's bye was Week 5, so Walker and Johnson have no bye left, and Dominic's Week 11 bye hole shrinks to Golden and Bijan Robinson now that Jacobs is gone. He also sells Tuten at his high, after a 159-scrimmage-yard, two-touchdown Week 8, and Tuten was a game-time decision this week with an ankle and foot injury.
The cost. Jacobs had 23.20 for him in Week 8 after returning from the Commissioner's Exempt List (21 carries, 70% of snaps), and Tuten had 29.9 on FantasyPros' scoring. Behind Walker and Robinson his running backs are Johnson, Coleman, Spears and B. Robinson Jr.
Why it makes sense for Michael
The backfield was broken. Love (ankle) and Montgomery are on injured reserve, Sampson (8.65) cost $163 and Knight projects at 5.10. Walker was the only back he could count on, and the trade turns one back into two with roles.
Tuten has a real job. Jacksonville is 5-2 off a 42-7 win over Indianapolis, and Tuten had 159 scrimmage yards and two touchdowns in it. FantasyPros logs 110 carries, 492 rushing yards and three rushing touchdowns, plus 15 catches for 181 yards and three receiving touchdowns, over the seven games it shows. Jacobs is back from the Commissioner's Exempt List and had 21 carries and 70% of the snaps in his first game.
The cost is the ceiling and the stack. Walker is projected at 21.99 and Jacobs and Tuten at 13.95 and 13.40, which is why Michael's Week 9 projection fell 9.53 points to 127.93. Lawrence and Tuten are both Jaguars, so a bad Jacksonville day now hits his quarterback and his top back together. The receivers are thin (Antonio Williams 7.54, Odunze 11.48 and Likely 11.46 in the starting spots), and if A.J. Brown and DeVonta Smith get healthy, those are the slots that improve most.
The calendar hurts a little. Jacobs and Sampson are both on bye in Week 11, and Michael plays Dalton that week.
BEFORE is last issue's odds, TRADE ALONE changes only the projections the trade touches, and NOW also counts the Week 9 power rankings and every other new projection. The model only sees the Week 9 projection change, not whether Walker's role holds, so it understates Dominic's gain if it does.
| DOMINIC | BEFORE | TRADE ALONE | NOW |
|---|---|---|---|
| Week 9 projection | 167.38 | 174.72 | 174.72 |
| Make playoffs | 99.9% | 99.9% | 99.9% |
| Top four | 86.9% | 88.5% | 88.8% |
| No. 1 seed | 11.7% | 13.0% | 13.3% |
| Win the title | 23.1% | 25.1% | 25.2% |
| MICHAEL | BEFORE | TRADE ALONE | NOW |
|---|---|---|---|
| Week 9 projection | 137.46 | 127.93 | 127.93 |
| Make playoffs | 83.4% | 80.4% | 76.1% |
| Top four | 53.8% | 50.1% | 44.5% |
| No. 1 seed | 1.7% | 1.4% | 1.1% |
| Win the title | 7.1% | 5.9% | 4.6% |
The Week 12 game. The teams meet that week with Walker and Johnson on Dominic's side and Tuten and Jacobs on Michael's. It is a direct seeding game for both.
Sources: Sleeper Week 9 lineups and projections; FantasyPros game logs for Walker, Johnson and Tuten (the logs list only the games shown, and their scoring is not this league's full PPR, so only touches, yards and touchdowns are quoted); the Week 9 injury report. Odds are from the same 300,000-run simulation as the Futures section.
Waivers ran Wednesday, but no one has set a final lineup, so these projections will still move. Sleeper currently shows Chris at 98.51, Nathaniel B. at 105.11 and Aayush at 123.36, but those are early numbers and will move. The lines below use Sleeper's numbers as they stand.
Sleeper projects Dominic at 174.72 against Dylan's 136.09, a 38.63-point gap, with Walker and Johnson on his roster, before lineups are set.
Week 8 sent the favorites 0-6 against the spread and left Matthew 7-1 and Aayush holding the last playoff spot at 2-6. Dominic, Michael, Dalton and Nathaniel B. are all 5-3, but only the first three hold record seeds, because Nathaniel B. is 79.4 points behind the last points spot.
The wild cards are Tommy (4-4), Nick (3-5) and Aayush (2-6), separated by 0.30 points between Nick and Aayush. Dylan is 14.4 points behind Aayush and plays Dominic this week, Aayush plays Nathaniel B., and Michael plays Damon, the Pollard trade partners, who are the Matchup of the Week. Tommy plays Matthew, the closest game on the board by a projection.
| MANAGER | W-L | PTS | STRK | WC | PO% | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | MUMatthew | 7-1 | 1247.0 | ▲4 | – | >99% |
| 2 | DDominic | 5-3 | 1203.9 | ▲1 | – | >99% |
| 3 | MMichael | 5-3 | 1094.0 | ▼3 | – | 76% |
| 4 | DDDalton | 5-3 | 1064.5 | ▼2 | – | 80% |
| 5 | TTommy | 4-4 | 1081.3 | ▲2 | +22.0 | 87% |
| 6 | NNick | 3-5 | 1059.6 | ▼2 | +0.3 | 67% |
| 7 | AAayush | 2-6 | 1059.3 | ▼1 | line | 55% |
| 8 | BNathaniel B. | 5-3 | 979.9 | ▲3 | -79.4 | 31% |
| 9 | DRAlex | 4-4 | 996.9 | ▲2 | -62.4 | 29% |
| 10 | CChris | 4-4 | 881.1 | ▼1 | -178.2 | 5% |
| 11 | DYDylan | 2-6 | 1044.9 | ▼3 | -14.4 | 60% |
| 12 | DADamon | 2-6 | 949.2 | ▲1 | -110.1 | 9% |
Losers bracket: bottom 5, ordered by record
WC: points ahead of (+) or behind (−) the last wild card, Aayush at 1,059.3
PO%: chance to make the playoffs, from a simulation of the rest of the season
Nathaniel B. Pays $175 for Adonai Mitchell and Drops Bourne
Read the story
Nathaniel B. won WR Adonai Mitchell (NYJ) for $175 against four bids, the biggest bid of the week, and dropped Kendrick Bourne, who fractured his tibia in Arizona's win over Dallas and is out for the season. Bourne had 3.90 in his lineup in Week 8. Nathaniel B. is 5-3 but outside the playoff field, 79.4 points behind the last points spot, and plays Aayush this week.
Michael Pays $163 for Dylan Sampson and Swaps Kickers for Free
Read the story
Michael won RB Dylan Sampson (CLE) for $163 and dropped WR Ted Hurst III. He also picked up kicker Tyler Bass (BUF) for $0 and dropped Chad Ryland, and he also dropped WR Elic Ayomanor. Jeremiyah Love left Arizona's game with a new ankle injury and was ruled out after halftime, and Michael has lost three straight, so the backfield is the reason for the $163.
Dominic Churns His Roster: Four Drops, Four Adds
Read the story
Dominic dropped QB Jacoby Brissett, the Bears defense and TE Chig Okonkwo on Tuesday, then added RB Tyjae Spears and WR Reggie Virgil for $2 each, the Chiefs defense, and WR Brandon Aiyuk (SF), dropping Virgil. Brissett had 4.46 as his starting quarterback in Week 8 while San Francisco, and Brock Purdy, was on bye.
Tommy Pays $90 for Mike Gesicki; Matthew Swaps Defenses for $12
Read the story
Tommy won TE Mike Gesicki (CIN) for $90 and dropped Kalif Raymond. Matthew paid $12 against one other bid for the Texans defense, dropping the Commanders, and Damon paid $5 for the Buccaneers defense, dropping the Bengals. Alex added WR Chimere Dike for $55 and RB Chris Rodriguez Jr. for $31, and Dylan paid $35 for TE Terrance Ferguson after dropping Tyreek Hill. Damon also added QB Gardner Minshew II.
The trade. On Oct. 13, Michael sent Tony Pollard, Jonathan Taylor and Marvin Harrison to Damon for A.J. Brown, Jeremiyah Love and $200 of FAAB. Since then Michael has lost three straight, Damon has won two of three, and the two teams now play each other. In Week 7 Pollard (36.50) and Taylor (19.00) scored 55.50 for Damon, and in Week 8 Pollard had 28.70 against Nick, while Love scored 2.30 for Michael and left with a new ankle injury, ruled out after halftime.
The form. Michael is 5-3 and the third seed with 1,093.98 points, but he scored 80.28 and 94.20 in his last two games and paid $163 for Dylan Sampson. Damon is 2-6 with the most points against in the league, but he scored 130.96 and added Gardner Minshew II.
The number. Sleeper now has Michael at 127.93 and Damon at 133.02, so Damon is the favorite by 5.09 points and the line is 5. Michael was at 137.46 before the Walker trade, when he was the favorite by 4.4.
The 5-3 is three weeks old. Michael started 5-0 and has lost three straight, scoring 160.64, 80.28 and 94.20. Two games, 188.50 in Week 1 and 181.28 in Week 4, are 369.78 of his 1,093.98 points (34%), and outside them he averages 120.7. His last two scores, 80.28 and 94.20, are the two lowest of his season.
The backfield keeps breaking. Jeremiyah Love scored 2.30 and left Arizona's game with a new ankle injury, ruled out after halftime with no timeline. Michael paid $163 for Dylan Sampson and dropped Ted Hurst III, picked up kicker Tyler Bass for $0 and dropped Chad Ryland, and dropped Elic Ayomanor. His four Week 8 pickups (Antonio Williams, Ryland, Ayomanor and Mason Taylor) scored 30.60 combined.
The schedule is the problem. He plays Damon this week, then Tommy, Dalton, Dominic and Nathaniel B. Sleeper has him at 127.93 against Damon's 133.02 after the trade, and three of those last four opponents are in the top five in points.
The case for him: he is still third in points (1,093.98) and has allowed the third-fewest points (1,020.00). The record says third seed; the scoring since Week 6 says a team that needs Sampson to work.
The record is the weakest part of his case. Tommy is 4-4 but fourth in the league in points (1,081.32) and has allowed the fewest (972.80), a point differential of +108.52, second only to Matthew (+155.40). His four losses came with 94.22, 144.32, 113.90 and 75.38, and the 144.32 loss in Week 2 was a score that wins most weeks.
The offense has settled. He has won two in a row, scoring 142.64 and 143.56, and in Week 8 Drake Maye had 26.46, Jahmyr Gibbs 24.80, Jaylen Warren 21.30, Dalton Kincaid 18.60 and Rashee Rice 18.30. His 197.76 in Week 5 is the highest score of the season. He paid $90 for Mike Gesicki and dropped Kalif Raymond.
The schedule helps. After Matthew this week he plays Michael, Nick, Damon and Chris. The last three are 9-15 combined. The simulation, which now counts his Weeks 5 to 8 scoring, gives him a 87% chance to make the playoffs and the third-best title odds in the league. He holds the fifth seed on points, 22.0 ahead of Aayush, and the risk is Week 9, since a loss to Matthew would leave him 4-5.
| MATCHUP | SPREAD (-110) | MONEYLINE | TOTAL | PICK |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dominic vs. Dylan | Dominic -38.5 | Dominic -257 · Dylan +257 | 311 | Dylan +38.5 |
| Nathaniel B. vs. Aayush | Aayush -18 | Aayush -186 · Nathaniel B. +186 | 228.5 | Nathaniel B. +18 |
| Michael vs. Damon | Damon -5 | Damon -117 · Michael +117 | 261 | Michael +5 |
| Tommy vs. Matthew | Matthew -3 | Matthew -108 · Tommy +108 | 299.5 | Matthew -3 |
| Nick vs. Dalton | Nick -4 | Nick -113 · Dalton +113 | 261 | Dalton +4 |
| Alex vs. Chris | Alex -27.5 | Alex -257 · Chris +257 | 224.5 | Chris +27.5 |
Lines will move when lineups are set. Spreads and totals are Sleeper's projection gaps, updated for the Walker trade. The moneylines on the two games the trade touched are the Chronicle's estimates. Lines are for fun only.
Big number is the price to win the title. The bar shows title probability, and the arrow is movement since Week 8.
Matthew Is the Favorite at +225, Dominic Second at +300 After the Trade
Matthew is 7-1 with the most points in the league (1,247.0) and a locked playoff spot, but his quarterback is headed to injured reserve. Dominic, 5-3 and second in points, is second at +300, followed by Tommy (+800), Dalton (+1200) and Nick (+1500). The Walker trade alone moves Dominic from +325 to about +300 for the title and Michael from +1300 to about +1600 (his title chance goes from 7.1% to 5.9% on the trade, and to 4.6% once the new Week 9 projections and rankings are counted). Michael's odds to make the playoffs fall from 83% to 76%.
Chris Is the Favorite to Lose the Toilet Bowl at +225, Damon Next at +425
Last place goes to whoever loses the toilet bowl, not to the worst record. Chris (4-4) has the fewest points in the league (881.08, 110.1 a game, and 102.2 since Week 5), which the simulation treats as a weak team that could land in the bottom three. Damon (2-6) has the most points against (1,127.02) but has scored 135.2 a game since Week 5, so his odds are lower than they were before the trends were counted. The favorites in order are Chris (+225), Damon (+425) and Aayush (+750). Chris's odds are shorter than last week because Sleeper now projects him at 98.51 and his playoff chance fell to 5%.
Odds come from a simulation of the rest of the 13-week regular season using the actual remaining schedule, and the seven-team playoff (top 4 on record, then the next three on points), using current records, points scored, scoring since Week 5, the Week 9 power rankings and the Week 9 projections after the trade. The title is won by winning the playoffs, including the two-week final. Last place goes to the loser of the toilet bowl, which is modeled as a ladder among the bottom three teams after the regular season (11th plays 12th, and the loser plays 10th). Prices are capped at -2000 and +10000. Lines are for fun only.
Five weeks left. Top four by record make it (ties go to points), and the next three highest scorers take the wild cards. Tap a team to open its full path.
Playoff odds. Green edge means scoring is up since Week 5, red means down.
HOW THE NUMBERS WORK
Every number is from 300,000 simulated finishes of Weeks 9 to 13 on the real schedule. Team strength is 30% Sleeper projections, 30% the power-rankings number, 25% scoring in Weeks 5 to 8 and 15% season scoring, so a team that has heated up or cooled off moves the odds. Each team’s game score varies by 27 points. It is a model, not a guarantee. Week 9 lines on the Betting Board are unchanged. NFL byes: Week 9 PIT, TEN. Week 10 CHI, DEN, PHI, TB. Week 11 ATL, CLE, GB, LAR, NE, SEA. Week 12 none. Week 13 BAL, IND, LV, NYJ.
| SEED | MANAGER | REC | PTS |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Matthew | 7-1 | 1,247.02 |
| 2 | Dominic | 5-3 | 1,203.86 |
| 3 | Michael | 5-3 | 1,093.98 |
| 4 | Dalton | 5-3 | 1,064.48 |
| 5 | Tommy | 4-4 | 1,081.32 |
| 6 | Nick | 3-5 | 1,059.58 |
| 7 | Aayush | 2-6 | 1,059.28 |
| — | Dylan | 2-6 | 1,044.86 |
Seeds 1-4 are top four by record, 5-7 are wild cards by points. Only seed 1 gets a bye. Nathaniel B. is 5-3 but sits outside on the points tiebreak.
| FINAL RECORD | TOP FOUR | PLAYOFFS |
|---|---|---|
| 5-8 | <0.1% | 38% |
| 6-7 | <1% | 41% |
| 7-6 | 24% | 57% |
| 8-5 | 88% | 93% |
| 9-4 | >99% | >99.9% |
Across all simulations and teams. A 7-6 or 6-7 team can still get in because wild cards go to the best scorers outside the top four.
| MANAGER | WK 1-4 | WK 5-8 | CHANGE | TREND |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Damon | 102.0 | 135.2 | +33.2 | Surging |
| Alex | 118.1 | 131.1 | +13.0 | Rising |
| Matthew | 151.1 | 160.6 | +9.5 | Steady at the top |
| Tommy | 130.5 | 139.8 | +9.3 | Volatile, bouncing back |
| Dylan | 126.3 | 134.9 | +8.7 | Rising |
| Nathaniel B. | 119.2 | 125.8 | +6.6 | Rising |
| Dalton | 132.3 | 133.8 | +1.6 | Slightly cooling |
| Nick | 134.3 | 130.6 | -3.8 | Flat |
| Dominic | 154.3 | 146.6 | -7.7 | Cooling |
| Chris | 118.0 | 102.2 | -15.8 | Sliding |
| Aayush | 148.7 | 116.1 | -32.6 | Sliding |
| Michael | 158.5 | 115.0 | -43.6 | Sliding |
Points per game. These trends are already built into the odds.
#1Matthew7-1▬>99.9%PLAYOFFS
Matthew is 7-1 and leads the league in points by 43.2, with a +155.40 point differential, the best in the league. His remaining opponents are 15-25 combined, with Dylan twice.
The simulation, which now weights Weeks 5 to 8 scoring and the post-trade rosters, has the team at >99.9% to make the playoffs (>99% through a top-four record and <1% as a wild card), and 81% for the No. 1 seed and the only bye. By wins in Weeks 9 to 13, the odds to get in are 99% with 0 wins, >99.9% with 1 win, >99.9% with 2 wins, >99.9% with 3 wins, >99.9% with 4 wins, >99.9% with 5 wins.
At the Weeks 5 to 8 pace he finishes with about 2,050 points, 342 above the median wild-card bar of 1,708.
Matthew's core has held its level, and the one piece that has dropped is at quarterback. In Week 8 Brock Bowers had 28.20, D'Andre Swift 27.90 on three touchdowns and Christian Watson 17.30 on a cracked rib. Lamar Jackson's 0.00 and his thumb surgery are the problem, and Kirk Cousins scored 34.18 on the bench.
| PLAYER | WK 1-4 | SINCE | CHANGE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jaxon Smith-Njigba (WR) | 29.2 | 26.0 (Wk 5, 7, 8) | -3.2 |
He holds the No. 1 seed at 7-1, two games ahead of the 5-3 group. If he falls out of the top four, the points route is the backup: he is first in points, 187.74 points ahead of the last wild-card spot.
120.5 last three63%56%
123.7 last three67%61%
125.3 last three75%69%
- Week 13: Damon over Dominic (+11 pts)
- Week 11: Alex over Dominic (+11 pts)
- Week 10: Aayush over Dominic (+11 pts)
Change in No. 1 seed odds, in points.
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RECORD | 7-6 | 8-5 | 9-4 | 10-3 | 11-2 | 12-1 |
| IN | 99% | >99.9% | >99.9% | >99.9% | >99.9% | >99.9% |
| TOP 4 | 56% | 99% | >99.9% | >99.9% | >99.9% | >99.9% |
135.2 ppg56%>99.9%>99%
130.6 ppg61%>99.9%>99%
122.5 ppg69%>99.9%>99%
130.6 ppg61%>99.9%>99%
132.4 ppg65%>99.9%>99%
IF WIN and IF LOSS are his playoff odds after that result.
ROSTER NOTES
The problem is the quarterback. Lamar Jackson hurt his right thumb on his first snap back, needs surgery and is headed to injured reserve, potentially for the season, and Baltimore's other quarterbacks are also hurt (Tyler Huntley has turf toe and Joe Fagnano an ankle). Kirk Cousins scored 34.18 on Matthew's bench in Week 8 and is the obvious replacement. The rest of the core held up: Brock Bowers had 28.20 on 7 catches for 92 yards and two touchdowns, D'Andre Swift 27.90 on three touchdowns, Jaxon Smith-Njigba 23.80 on 11 targets, and Christian Watson 17.30 on a cracked rib. He swapped the Commanders defense for the Texans for $12. Week 13 is the risk: Jackson, Cousins and Bowers are all on bye in the regular-season finale, so Matthew needs a quarterback, a tight end and a plan before then.
#2Dominic5-3▼99.9%PLAYOFFS
Dominic is 5-3 and second in points (1,203.86, +103.12). His remaining opponents are 15-25 combined (Dylan, Aayush, Alex, Michael and Damon), and the Week 12 game with Michael is a direct seeding game.
The simulation, which now weights Weeks 5 to 8 scoring and the post-trade rosters, has the team at 99.9% to make the playoffs (89% through a top-four record and 11% as a wild card), and 13% for the No. 1 seed and the only bye. By wins in Weeks 9 to 13, the odds to get in are 97% with 0 wins, 99% with 1 win, >99% with 2 wins, >99.9% with 3 wins, >99.9% with 4 wins, >99.9% with 5 wins.
At the Weeks 5 to 8 pace he finishes with about 1,937 points, 229 above the median wild-card bar of 1,708.
Week 8 showed where the offense stands: Ja'Marr Chase had 31.10 on 11 catches for 141 yards, Josh Jacobs 23.20 in his first game back (he is now Michael's), Matthew Golden 20.90 and Amon-Ra St. Brown 12.60. The cooling is at quarterback, where Jacoby Brissett had 4.46 and was dropped, and in the trade, since Moore and Wilson gave Chris 43.40 in Week 8. The team averaged 154.3 in Weeks 1 to 4 and 146.6 since.
He holds the No. 2 seed on record. The nearest team outside the top four on record is Tommy at 4-4; Nathaniel B. is also 5-3 and loses the tiebreak on points, 979.86 to 1,203.86. If he falls out of the top four, the points route is the backup: he is second in points, 144.58 points ahead of the last wild-card spot.
123.7 last three87%63%
111.7 last three91%68%
140.2 last three88%65%
- Week 11: Nathaniel B. over Matthew (+14 pts)
- Week 12: Dylan over Matthew (+14 pts)
- Week 10: Dylan over Matthew (+14 pts)
Change in No. 1 seed odds, in points.
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RECORD | 5-8 | 6-7 | 7-6 | 8-5 | 9-4 | 10-3 |
| IN | 97% | 99% | >99% | >99.9% | >99.9% | >99.9% |
| TOP 4 | <1% | 1% | 67% | >99% | >99.9% | >99.9% |
130.6 ppg63%>99%>99%
132.4 ppg67%>99%>99%
124.6 ppg67%>99%>99%
136.7 ppg68%>99%>99%
118.6 ppg65%>99%>99%
IF WIN and IF LOSS are his playoff odds after that result.
ROSTER NOTES
Ja'Marr Chase is the engine: 31.10 on 11 catches for 141 yards and a touchdown, 16 targets and a 100% route share. Josh Jacobs had 23.20 in his first game off the Commissioner's Exempt List (21 carries, 70% of snaps, plus a receiving touchdown) before he went to Michael in the trade for Kenneth Walker III and Emmett Johnson, Matthew Golden 20.90 on a team-high 13 targets, and Amon-Ra St. Brown 12.60. The quarterback slot was the hole: Jacoby Brissett had 4.46 while San Francisco was on bye, and Dominic dropped him on Tuesday and added Tyjae Spears, Brandon Aiyuk and the Chiefs defense. Jonah Coleman, a $426 claim, came back from injured reserve with a 51-yard gain but did not start. Week 11 is the one to watch: Golden and Bijan Robinson are both on bye. Walker and Johnson (KC) have no bye left.
#3Michael5-3▼76%PLAYOFFS
Michael is 5-3 but has lost three straight, averaging 111.7 over Weeks 6 to 8 against 151.8 in Weeks 1 to 5. His opponents are 21-19 combined (Damon, Tommy, Dalton, Dominic and Nathaniel B.), the toughest closing run of any current top-four team.
The simulation, which now weights Weeks 5 to 8 scoring and the post-trade rosters, has the team at 76% to make the playoffs (44% through a top-four record and 32% as a wild card). By wins in Weeks 9 to 13, the odds to get in are 28% with 0 wins, 50% with 1 win, 76% with 2 wins, 98% with 3 wins, >99.9% with 4 wins, >99.9% with 5 wins.
At the Weeks 5 to 8 pace he finishes with about 1,669 points, 39 below the median wild-card bar of 1,708.
Lawrence is the one piece of the lineup that has improved. Everywhere else it has thinned: in Week 8 Jeremiyah Love had 2.30 and left with an ankle injury, Kenneth Walker III (traded to Dominic since) had 12.40, Rome Odunze 12.70 and Tyler Warren 5.80, and four waiver pickups started for 30.60 combined. The 80.28 and 94.20 are his two lowest scores of the year.
| PLAYER | WK 1-4 | SINCE | CHANGE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trevor Lawrence (QB) | 20.8 | 29.5 (Wk 5, 6, 8) | +8.7 |
He holds the No. 3 seed on record. The nearest team outside the top four on record is Tommy at 4-4; Nathaniel B. is also 5-3 and loses the tiebreak on points, 979.86 to 1,093.98. If he falls out of the top four, the points route is the backup: he is third in points, 34.70 points ahead of the last wild-card spot.
120.5 last three61%40%
128.3 last three65%45%
125.3 last three74%53%
If he misses the top four, the three best scorers outside it take the wild cards. The median cutoff is 1,708 points. He is already scoring above that pace. Reaching 1,732 (the 75th percentile) takes 127.6 a game.
- Week 11: Matthew over Nathaniel B. (+4 pts)
- Week 11: Dominic over Alex (+3 pts)
- Week 12: Matthew over Dylan (+3 pts)
Change in playoff odds, in points.
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RECORD | 5-8 | 6-7 | 7-6 | 8-5 | 9-4 | 10-3 |
| IN | 28% | 50% | 76% | 98% | >99.9% | >99.9% |
| TOP 4 | <1% | <1% | 26% | 91% | >99% | >99.9% |
118.6 ppg47%86%67%
135.2 ppg40%88%68%
133.1 ppg45%87%67%
150.5 ppg32%88%70%
122.5 ppg53%86%64%
IF WIN and IF LOSS are his playoff odds after that result.
ROSTER NOTES
Trevor Lawrence is the steady piece (25.40 on 10 of 14 for 210 yards and three touchdowns in a 42-7 win). The backfield is the problem: Jeremiyah Love scored 2.30 and left with a new ankle injury, ruled out after halftime with no timeline, so he paid $163 for Dylan Sampson. Rome Odunze had 12.70, Kenneth Walker III 12.40 on 25 touches (he now plays for Dominic), and Tyler Warren, back from a groin injury, had 5.80 on 10 targets. Michael got Bhayshul Tuten and Josh Jacobs for Walker and Emmett Johnson. Four pickups started in Week 8 (Antonio Williams 10.40, Ryland, Ayomanor and Mason Taylor) for 30.60 combined, and Ryland and Ayomanor are now gone. Byes cost him in Week 10 (Odunze and the Bears defense), Week 11 (Jacobs and Sampson) and Week 13 (Warren).
#4Dalton5-3▼80%PLAYOFFS
Dalton is 5-3 with the second-fewest points against (995.26) and a +69.22 point differential, and he has lost two straight. His remaining opponents are 18-22 combined (Nick, Chris, Michael, Aayush and Alex).
The simulation, which now weights Weeks 5 to 8 scoring and the post-trade rosters, has the team at 80% to make the playoffs (64% through a top-four record and 16% as a wild card), and 2% for the No. 1 seed and the only bye. By wins in Weeks 9 to 13, the odds to get in are 12% with 0 wins, 30% with 1 win, 61% with 2 wins, 97% with 3 wins, >99% with 4 wins, >99.9% with 5 wins.
At the Weeks 5 to 8 pace he finishes with about 1,734 points, 26 above the median wild-card bar of 1,708.
Chuba Hubbard leads the offense with 24.90 on 91% of the snaps and 7 catches, with James Cook at 18.10, Caleb Williams at 15.98, Garrett Wilson at 14.30 and Cairo Santos at 12.20 in Week 8. The team averaged 135.9 in Weeks 1 to 5 and 128.3 in the last three (143.40, 113.72, 127.88), a small slide and not a collapse.
He holds the No. 4 seed on record. The nearest team outside the top four on record is Tommy at 4-4; Nathaniel B. is also 5-3 and loses the tiebreak on points, 979.86 to 1,064.48. If he falls out of the top four, the points route is the backup: he is 5th in points, 5.20 points ahead of the last wild-card spot.
132.7 last three63%51%
111.7 last three70%55%
131.3 last three68%55%
If he misses the top four, the three best scorers outside it take the wild cards. The median cutoff is 1,708 points. He is already scoring above that pace. Reaching 1,732 (the 75th percentile) takes 133.5 a game.
- Week 11: Matthew over Nathaniel B. (+4 pts)
- Week 11: Dominic over Alex (+3 pts)
- Week 10: Damon over Alex (+3 pts)
Change in playoff odds, in points.
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RECORD | 5-8 | 6-7 | 7-6 | 8-5 | 9-4 | 10-3 |
| IN | 12% | 30% | 61% | 97% | >99% | >99.9% |
| TOP 4 | <1% | <1% | 22% | 90% | >99% | >99.9% |
132.4 ppg51%90%69%
110.1 ppg66%87%66%
136.7 ppg55%89%68%
132.4 ppg55%89%68%
124.6 ppg55%90%67%
IF WIN and IF LOSS are his playoff odds after that result.
ROSTER NOTES
Chuba Hubbard is the workhorse: 24.90 on 22 carries and 91% of the snaps plus 7 catches. James Cook had 18.10, Caleb Williams 15.98 (24 of 34 for 247 yards and a touchdown), Garrett Wilson 14.30 and Cairo Santos 12.20, while kicker Justin Tucker scored 0.00. The Rams defense had 11.00. The danger is Week 10, when Williams, Colston Loveland and Santos are all Bears on bye in the same week, which wipes out his quarterback, tight end and kicker against Chris. Week 11 (Rams defense and Zach Charbonnet) and Week 13 (Tucker and Wilson) cost him again.
#5Tommy4-4▬87%PLAYOFFS
Tommy is 4-4 but fourth in points (1,081.32) and has allowed the fewest (972.80), a +108.52 point differential that is second to Matthew. He faces Matthew, Michael, Nick, Damon and Chris, who are 21-19 combined, and the last three are 9-15.
The simulation, which now weights Weeks 5 to 8 scoring and the post-trade rosters, has the team at 87% to make the playoffs (40% through a top-four record and 47% as a wild card). By wins in Weeks 9 to 13, the odds to get in are 36% with 0 wins, 59% with 1 win, 79% with 2 wins, 93% with 3 wins, >99% with 4 wins, >99.9% with 5 wins.
At the Weeks 5 to 8 pace he finishes with about 1,780 points, 72 above the median wild-card bar of 1,708.
Maye is the biggest riser on the team and Gibbs has held a high level, so the lineup is stronger than the 4-4 record. In Week 8 Jaylen Warren had 21.30, Dalton Kincaid 18.60 and Rashee Rice 18.30. The 75.38 in Week 6 is the outlier that drags his three-game average.
| PLAYER | WK 1-4 | SINCE | CHANGE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Drake Maye (QB) | 15.7 | 35.5 (Wk 5, 7, 8) | +19.8 |
| Jahmyr Gibbs (RB) | 29.0 | 31.2 (Wk 5, 8) | +2.2 |
He holds the No. 5 seed on points, 21.74 points ahead of Nick for the next spot down and 36.46 points ahead of Dylan, the first team out.
155.1 last three63%44%
111.7 last three83%60%
132.7 last three76%55%
If he misses the top four, the three best scorers outside it take the wild cards. The median cutoff is 1,708 points. He is already scoring above that pace. Reaching 1,732 (the 75th percentile) takes 130.2 a game.
- Week 10: Dominic over Aayush (+3 pts)
- Week 9: Dominic over Dylan (+3 pts)
- Week 11: Dominic over Alex (+3 pts)
Change in playoff odds, in points.
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RECORD | 4-9 | 5-8 | 6-7 | 7-6 | 8-5 | 9-4 |
| IN | 36% | 59% | 79% | 93% | >99% | >99.9% |
| TOP 4 | <1% | <1% | <1% | 37% | 94% | >99% |
155.9 ppg44%93%82%
136.7 ppg60%92%79%
132.4 ppg55%93%80%
118.6 ppg56%92%80%
110.1 ppg70%91%78%
IF WIN and IF LOSS are his playoff odds after that result.
ROSTER NOTES
Drake Maye had 26.46 (16 of 20 for 199 yards, two touchdowns and a rushing touchdown), Jahmyr Gibbs 24.80 on 23 carries and 153 yards, Jaylen Warren 21.30 on 17 carries and 143 yards (he splits snaps nearly evenly with Rico Dowdle, 58% to 47%), Dalton Kincaid 18.60 and Rashee Rice 18.30. He paid $90 for Mike Gesicki and dropped Kalif Raymond. The byes are the story: Warren and the Steelers are off in Week 9 against Matthew, and Week 11 takes Maye, Drake London and Denzel Boston against Nick, which leaves him without a quarterback unless he finds one.
#6Nick3-5▬67%PLAYOFFS
Nick is 3-5 with two straight losses and holds the sixth seed on points, 0.30 ahead of Aayush (1,059.58 to 1,059.28). His remaining opponents are 21-19 combined and include Nathaniel B. twice, and his point differential is -7.14.
The simulation, which now weights Weeks 5 to 8 scoring and the post-trade rosters, has the team at 67% to make the playoffs (11% through a top-four record and 56% as a wild card). By wins in Weeks 9 to 13, the odds to get in are 13% with 0 wins, 32% with 1 win, 57% with 2 wins, 78% with 3 wins, 94% with 4 wins, >99% with 5 wins.
At the Weeks 5 to 8 pace he finishes with about 1,712 points, 4 above the median wild-card bar of 1,708.
Nick's Week 8 was deep but low on ceiling: Trey McBride 20.20, Jayden Daniels 16.98, W. Robinson 15.70, Stefon Diggs 12.80, McMillan 11.80, Dowdle 11.60 and Jeanty 10.30, with nobody above 20.20. The team spiked to 163.20 in Week 6 and has scored 121.10 and 113.78 since, so it is a 130-a-game team with no recent star game.
He holds the No. 6 seed on points, 0.30 points ahead of Aayush for the next spot down and 14.72 points ahead of Dylan, the first team out.
128.3 last three87%49%
120.5 last three86%45%
123.7 last three82%50%
If he misses the top four, the three best scorers outside it take the wild cards. The median cutoff is 1,708 points. He is already scoring above that pace. Reaching 1,732 (the 75th percentile) takes 134.5 a game.
- Week 9: Dominic over Dylan (+5 pts)
- Week 10: Dominic over Aayush (+5 pts)
- Week 11: Dominic over Alex (+5 pts)
Change in playoff odds, in points.
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RECORD | 3-10 | 4-9 | 5-8 | 6-7 | 7-6 | 8-5 |
| IN | 13% | 32% | 57% | 78% | 94% | >99% |
| TOP 4 | <1% | <1% | <1% | <1% | 38% | 96% |
133.1 ppg49%77%58%
122.5 ppg58%77%54%
135.2 ppg45%77%59%
122.5 ppg58%77%54%
130.6 ppg50%78%57%
IF WIN and IF LOSS are his playoff odds after that result.
ROSTER NOTES
Trey McBride had 20.20, Jayden Daniels 16.98 and Wan'Dale Robinson 15.70 (6 catches for 57 yards and a touchdown on 93% of snaps). Stefon Diggs had 12.80, Tetairoa McMillan 11.80 on 11 targets and Rico Dowdle 11.60, while Ashton Jeanty had 10.30 on two carries and a 45-yard catch as Mike Washington Jr. took over as the lead back in Las Vegas. Week 9 hits him immediately, with Dowdle (PIT) and Robinson (TEN) both on bye against Dalton, and Week 13 takes Jeanty. The Patriots defense is on bye in Week 11.
#7Aayush2-6▼55%PLAYOFFS
Aayush is 2-6 and holds the last wild card on points (1,059.28, seventh), 14.42 ahead of Dylan. He has the toughest schedule left at 24-16 combined (Nathaniel B., Dominic, Dylan, Dalton and Matthew), tied with Dylan, and his points against are the second most in the league (1,114.02).
The simulation, which now weights Weeks 5 to 8 scoring and the post-trade rosters, has the team at 55% to make the playoffs (1% through a top-four record and 54% as a wild card). By wins in Weeks 9 to 13, the odds to get in are 13% with 0 wins, 31% with 1 win, 53% with 2 wins, 75% with 3 wins, 90% with 4 wins, 98% with 5 wins.
At the Weeks 5 to 8 pace he finishes with about 1,640 points, 68 below the median wild-card bar of 1,708.
Aayush's decline is concentrated at wide receiver and the injury list. Prescott is steady at quarterback, but Lamb has fallen off sharply, Zay Flowers had 0.00 with no catches on five targets in Week 8, Breece Hall has been out five straight games and Jake Ferguson left with an ankle sprain. Chase Brown (16.10) and the Steelers defense (21.00) were the bright spots in the 83.20, the lowest score in the league.
| PLAYER | WK 1-4 | SINCE | CHANGE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dak Prescott (QB) | 24.6 | 22.6 (Wk 5, 7, 8) | -2.0 |
| CeeDee Lamb (WR) | 28.1 | 7.9 (Wk 5, 8) | -20.2 |
He holds the No. 7 seed by 14.42 points over Dylan (1,059.28 to 1,044.86). To be passed, Dylan needs to outscore him by more than that over five weeks, or 2.9 points a game more.
140.3 last three99%33%
128.3 last three>99%45%
155.1 last three99%35%
If he misses the top four, the three best scorers outside it take the wild cards. The median cutoff is 1,708 points. He is already scoring above that pace. Reaching 1,732 (the 75th percentile) takes 134.6 a game.
- Week 9: Dominic over Dylan (+5 pts)
- Week 11: Dominic over Alex (+5 pts)
- Week 11: Matthew over Nathaniel B. (+5 pts)
Change in playoff odds, in points.
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RECORD | 2-11 | 3-10 | 4-9 | 5-8 | 6-7 | 7-6 |
| IN | 13% | 31% | 53% | 75% | 90% | 98% |
| TOP 4 | <1% | <1% | <1% | <1% | <1% | 42% |
122.5 ppg54%66%42%
150.5 ppg33%67%49%
130.6 ppg45%68%44%
133.1 ppg45%67%45%
155.9 ppg35%68%48%
IF WIN and IF LOSS are his playoff odds after that result.
ROSTER NOTES
Week 8's 83.20 had three zeros in it: Breece Hall was out for a fifth straight game, Jake Ferguson left Dallas' game in the first half with an ankle sprain, and Zay Flowers had no catches on five targets. Baltimore's quarterback room is the Flowers problem, with Lamar Jackson headed to injured reserve and Tyler Huntley out with turf toe. Dak Prescott had 21.80 and CeeDee Lamb 12.80 (Dallas blew a 17-3 lead), Chase Brown had 16.10 and the Steelers defense 21.00. Hall is reportedly good to go in Week 9. The byes: the Steelers defense is off in Week 9 against Nathaniel B., Quinshon Judkins in Week 11, and Flowers and Hall in Week 13 against Matthew.
#8Nathaniel B.5-3▲31%PLAYOFFS
Nathaniel B. is 5-3 and on a three-game win streak, but his 979.86 points are 79.4 behind the last wild card, so he needs the record route. He plays Aayush, Nick, Matthew, Nick and Michael, who are 20-20 combined.
The simulation, which now weights Weeks 5 to 8 scoring and the post-trade rosters, has the team at 31% to make the playoffs (28% through a top-four record and 3% as a wild card). By wins in Weeks 9 to 13, the odds to get in are <1% with 0 wins, 1% with 1 win, 9% with 2 wins, 72% with 3 wins, >99% with 4 wins, >99.9% with 5 wins.
At the Weeks 5 to 8 pace he finishes with about 1,609 points, 99 below the median wild-card bar of 1,708.
Burrow is the engine of the whole team. In Week 8 Harold Fannin Jr. added 23.40, Braelon Allen 23.30 and the Jaguars defense 20.00, but Kendrick Bourne is out for the season. Be careful with the 169.18: 52.48 of it was one quarterback, and his Weeks 5 to 7 average was 111.3.
| PLAYER | WK 1-4 | SINCE | CHANGE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joe Burrow (QB) | 23.4 | 40.7 (Wk 5, 7, 8) | +17.2 |
He is outside the field right now. To take the last wild-card spot he must outscore Aayush (1,059.28) by more than 79.42 points over the last five weeks, or 15.9 a game more, while also holding off the teams behind him.
132.7 last three68%42%
132.7 last three68%42%
111.7 last three76%47%
If he misses the top four, the three best scorers outside it take the wild cards. The median cutoff is 1,708 points. 24.1 above his season average. Reaching 1,732 (the 75th percentile) takes 150.5 a game.
- Week 12: Damon over Tommy (+5 pts)
- Week 9: Damon over Michael (+4 pts)
- Week 9: Matthew over Tommy (+4 pts)
Change in playoff odds, in points.
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RECORD | 5-8 | 6-7 | 7-6 | 8-5 | 9-4 | 10-3 |
| IN | <1% | 1% | 9% | 72% | >99% | >99.9% |
| TOP 4 | <1% | <1% | 5% | 68% | 99% | >99.9% |
132.4 ppg46%47%18%
132.4 ppg42%49%18%
155.9 ppg31%52%22%
132.4 ppg42%49%18%
136.7 ppg47%49%15%
IF WIN and IF LOSS are his playoff odds after that result.
ROSTER NOTES
Joe Burrow had 52.48 (38 of 48 for 462 yards, five touchdown passes, three interceptions and a rushing touchdown), which was 31% of his 169.18, and the rest of the roster scores about 117. Harold Fannin Jr. had 23.40 and Braelon Allen 23.30 on 21 carries and 147 yards with Hall out, and the Jaguars defense had 20.00. He paid $175 for Adonai Mitchell and dropped Kendrick Bourne, who fractured his tibia and is out for the season. Week 11 takes Fannin (CLE) against Matthew, and Week 13 takes Allen and Mitchell (NYJ) against Michael, in the games that decide the record route.
#9Alex4-4▲29%PLAYOFFS
Alex is 4-4 and has won two straight, but he is ninth in points (996.90), 62.4 behind the last wild card, so he mostly needs the record route. His opponents are 20-20 combined, with Chris twice.
The simulation, which now weights Weeks 5 to 8 scoring and the post-trade rosters, has the team at 29% to make the playoffs (17% through a top-four record and 12% as a wild card). By wins in Weeks 9 to 13, the odds to get in are 1% with 0 wins, 3% with 1 win, 11% with 2 wins, 30% with 3 wins, 85% with 4 wins, >99% with 5 wins.
At the Weeks 5 to 8 pace he finishes with about 1,652 points, 56 below the median wild-card bar of 1,708.
Alex has a steady, elite quarterback in Josh Allen and a dependable supporting cast: in Week 8 Jameson Williams had 17.00, Rachaad White 14.00, Chase McLaughlin 13.20, Kyren Williams 12.90 and Saquon Barkley 12.40. His scores of 131, 121, 152 and 121 are four straight games between 121 and 152, and he picked up Dike ($55) and Rodriguez ($31) in the last week.
| PLAYER | WK 1-4 | SINCE | CHANGE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Josh Allen (QB) | 31.9 | 32.5 (Wk 5, 8) | +0.7 |
He is outside the field right now. To take the last wild-card spot he must outscore Aayush (1,059.28) by more than 62.38 points over the last five weeks, or 12.5 a game more, while also holding off the teams behind him.
140.2 last three78%47%
140.3 last three67%33%
128.3 last three82%45%
If he misses the top four, the three best scorers outside it take the wild cards. The median cutoff is 1,708 points. 18.5 above his season average. Reaching 1,732 (the 75th percentile) takes 147.1 a game.
- Week 11: Matthew over Nathaniel B. (+4 pts)
- Week 10: Chris over Dalton (+3 pts)
- Week 9: Damon over Michael (+2 pts)
Change in playoff odds, in points.
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RECORD | 4-9 | 5-8 | 6-7 | 7-6 | 8-5 | 9-4 |
| IN | 1% | 3% | 11% | 30% | 85% | >99% |
| TOP 4 | <1% | <1% | <1% | 9% | 76% | >99% |
110.1 ppg61%38%15%
118.6 ppg47%42%17%
150.5 ppg33%47%20%
110.1 ppg61%38%15%
133.1 ppg45%44%17%
IF WIN and IF LOSS are his playoff odds after that result.
ROSTER NOTES
Josh Allen had 31.56 and passed Jim Kelly for the franchise touchdown record, Jameson Williams 17.00, Rachaad White 14.00, kicker Chase McLaughlin 13.20, Kyren Williams 12.90 and Saquon Barkley 12.40 on 13 carries at 2.3 yards each. He added Chimere Dike for $55 and Chris Rodriguez Jr. for $31. The byes cost him twice: Barkley and McLaughlin are off in Week 10 against Damon, and Week 11 against Dominic takes Kyren Williams, KC Concepcion, Kyle Pitts and the Seahawks defense, four starters in one week.
#10Chris4-4▼5%PLAYOFFS
Chris is 4-4 with the fewest points in the league (881.08, 110.1 a game), so the points route is nearly gone. He plays Alex, Dalton, Damon, Alex and Tommy, who are 19-21 combined.
The simulation, which now weights Weeks 5 to 8 scoring and the post-trade rosters, has the team at 5% to make the playoffs (5% through a top-four record and <0.1% as a wild card). By wins in Weeks 9 to 13, the odds to get in are <1% with 0 wins, <1% with 1 win, <1% with 2 wins, 2% with 3 wins, 67% with 4 wins, 99% with 5 wins.
At the Weeks 5 to 8 pace he finishes with about 1,392 points, 316 below the median wild-card bar of 1,708.
Stafford is steady-to-up, but it has not been enough. Michael Wilson (26.80, playing through two broken ribs) and DJ Moore (16.60) arrived by trade in Week 8, Josh Downs had 12.30 and the Bills defense 15.00. The Week 6 total of 65.28 came with Skattebo, Juwan Johnson, Lloyd and the Texans defense combining for 2.00, and he has not topped 107 in any game since Week 5.
| PLAYER | WK 1-4 | SINCE | CHANGE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Matthew Stafford (QB) | 19.9 | 22.3 (Wk 5, 8) | +2.4 |
He is outside the field right now. To take the last wild-card spot he must outscore Aayush (1,059.28) by more than 178.20 points over the last five weeks, or 35.6 a game more, while also holding off the teams behind him.
128.3 last three83%34%
131.3 last three83%39%
120.5 last three80%30%
If he misses the top four, the three best scorers outside it take the wild cards. The median cutoff is 1,708 points. 56.2 above his season average. Reaching 1,732 (the 75th percentile) takes 170.2 a game.
- Week 12: Aayush over Dalton (+1 pts)
- Week 11: Matthew over Nathaniel B. (+1 pts)
- Week 9: Aayush over Nathaniel B. (+1 pts)
Change in playoff odds, in points.
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RECORD | 4-9 | 5-8 | 6-7 | 7-6 | 8-5 | 9-4 |
| IN | <1% | <1% | <1% | 2% | 67% | 99% |
| TOP 4 | <1% | <1% | <1% | 2% | 67% | 99% |
124.6 ppg39%11%1%
133.1 ppg34%12%1%
118.6 ppg36%11%2%
124.6 ppg39%11%1%
135.2 ppg30%13%1%
IF WIN and IF LOSS are his playoff odds after that result.
ROSTER NOTES
Michael Wilson had 26.80 (8 catches for 111 yards and a touchdown) while playing through two broken ribs, DJ Moore 16.60 (both came from Dominic in the trade), the Bills defense 15.00 on a $5 claim, Josh Downs 12.30 and Matthew Stafford 11.28. The holes were Emanuel Wilson and Chris Godwin, who both scored 0.00, Omarion Hampton at 4.70 and Sam LaPorta at 6.50. The byes: kicker Chris Boswell (PIT) in Week 9 against Alex, Godwin (TB) in Week 10, Stafford and Emanuel Wilson in Week 11 against Damon, and Downs in Week 13 against Tommy.
#11Dylan2-6▲60%PLAYOFFS
Dylan is 2-6 and has lost three straight, but he is eighth in points (1,044.86) and only 14.42 behind the last wild card. He has the toughest schedule at 24-16 combined, tied with Aayush, with Matthew twice.
The simulation, which now weights Weeks 5 to 8 scoring and the post-trade rosters, has the team at 60% to make the playoffs (1% through a top-four record and 60% as a wild card). By wins in Weeks 9 to 13, the odds to get in are 17% with 0 wins, 35% with 1 win, 58% with 2 wins, 78% with 3 wins, 90% with 4 wins, 98% with 5 wins.
At the Weeks 5 to 8 pace he finishes with about 1,720 points, 12 above the median wild-card bar of 1,708.
In Week 8 Tee Higgins had 37.50 on 10 catches for 155 yards and two touchdowns, Jordan Love 28.52, Bucky Irving 21.00, Tucker Kraft 17.30 and T.J. Hockenson 15.80, and Makai Lemon had 11.70. After the 85.04 in Week 6 he scored 133.86 and 152.32.
He is outside the field right now. To take the last wild-card spot he must outscore Aayush (1,059.28) by more than 14.42 points over the last five weeks, or 2.9 a game more, while also holding off the teams behind him.
140.3 last three99%37%
155.1 last three99%39%
155.1 last three99%39%
If he misses the top four, the three best scorers outside it take the wild cards. The median cutoff is 1,708 points. 3.0 above his season average. Reaching 1,732 (the 75th percentile) takes 137.5 a game.
- Week 10: Dominic over Aayush (+6 pts)
- Week 11: Dominic over Alex (+5 pts)
- Week 13: Matthew over Aayush (+4 pts)
Change in playoff odds, in points.
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RECORD | 2-11 | 3-10 | 4-9 | 5-8 | 6-7 | 7-6 |
| IN | 17% | 35% | 58% | 78% | 90% | 98% |
| TOP 4 | <1% | <1% | <1% | <1% | <1% | 32% |
150.5 ppg37%71%54%
155.9 ppg39%71%53%
132.4 ppg55%71%48%
155.9 ppg39%72%53%
132.4 ppg50%71%49%
IF WIN and IF LOSS are his playoff odds after that result.
ROSTER NOTES
Tee Higgins had 37.50 on 10 of 11 for 155 yards and two touchdowns, Jordan Love 28.52, Bucky Irving 21.00, Tucker Kraft 17.30, T.J. Hockenson 15.80 and Makai Lemon 11.70. The 152.32 was the fourth-highest losing score of the season. He dropped Tyreek Hill and paid $35 for Terrance Ferguson. The byes are brutal in sequence: Irving and Lemon are off in Week 10 against Matthew, and Love, Kraft and Ferguson are off in Week 11 against Aayush, a game he probably has to win.
#12Damon2-6▲9%PLAYOFFS
Damon is 2-6 with the most points against in the league (1,127.02) and the second-fewest points scored (949.18). His opponents are 22-18 combined: Michael, Alex, Chris, Tommy and Dominic.
The simulation, which now weights Weeks 5 to 8 scoring and the post-trade rosters, has the team at 9% to make the playoffs (1% through a top-four record and 9% as a wild card). By wins in Weeks 9 to 13, the odds to get in are <1% with 0 wins, 1% with 1 win, 3% with 2 wins, 10% with 3 wins, 24% with 4 wins, 52% with 5 wins.
At the Weeks 5 to 8 pace he finishes with about 1,625 points, 83 below the median wild-card bar of 1,708.
Pollard has scored 36.50 and 28.70 in his last two games, Puka Nacua had 25.00 and Luther Burden 18.60 in Week 8. Allgeier left 36.10 on the bench that week, and Bryce Young (13.36) and Kelce (11.70) are the soft spots. He has scored 120 or more in four straight games.
He is outside the field right now. To take the last wild-card spot he must outscore Aayush (1,059.28) by more than 110.10 points over the last five weeks, or 22.0 a game more, while also holding off the teams behind him.
131.3 last three>99%53%
120.5 last three>99%44%
140.3 last three99%35%
If he misses the top four, the three best scorers outside it take the wild cards. The median cutoff is 1,708 points. 34.1 above his season average. Reaching 1,732 (the 75th percentile) takes 156.6 a game.
- Week 9: Dominic over Dylan (+2 pts)
- Week 10: Dominic over Aayush (+2 pts)
- Week 11: Matthew over Nathaniel B. (+2 pts)
Change in playoff odds, in points.
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RECORD | 2-11 | 3-10 | 4-9 | 5-8 | 6-7 | 7-6 |
| IN | <1% | 1% | 3% | 10% | 24% | 52% |
| TOP 4 | <1% | <1% | <1% | <1% | <1% | 22% |
136.7 ppg53%13%5%
124.6 ppg53%14%4%
110.1 ppg64%12%4%
135.2 ppg44%14%6%
150.5 ppg35%15%6%
IF WIN and IF LOSS are his playoff odds after that result.
ROSTER NOTES
Tony Pollard had 28.70 (21 carries, 117 yards and two touchdowns), Puka Nacua 25.00 on 11 catches, Luther Burden 18.60, Bryce Young 13.36 and Travis Kelce 11.70. Tyler Allgeier scored 36.10 on his bench and Caleb Douglas, a $309 claim, had 8.30. He added Gardner Minshew II, the Buccaneers defense and dropped J.K. Dobbins. The byes hit his top three scorers in three straight weeks: Pollard (TEN) in Week 9 against Michael, Burden (CHI) in Week 10 and Nacua (LAR) in Week 11, with Jonathan Taylor (IND) in Week 13.
Four ballots, 12 points for first place down to 1 for last. The maximum is 48. Gold cards were ranked in the same spot on all four ballots, and the range under each name shows how far the ballots spread. Ties go to the team with the higher best placement: Nick over Aayush (5th vs. 6th best). Movement is against the Week 8 panel. Records and scores are through Week 8.
The trade pushed the spread from 31.5 to 38.5, and that is a lot to lay on any team in one game. Dylan has scored 152.32 in a loss and is projected at 136.09.
Read the breakdown
Sleeper has Dominic at 174.72, the highest projection of the week and 7.34 higher than before he added Kenneth Walker III and Emmett Johnson from Michael for Josh Jacobs and Bhayshul Tuten, and Dylan at 136.09. Dominic scored 121.66 to beat Chris in Week 8 with Ja'Marr Chase at 31.10, and is second in points (1,203.86). Dylan lost with 152.32, the fourth-highest losing score of the season, and has lost three straight. He is 14.4 points behind the last playoff spot. Dylan dropped Tyreek Hill and paid $35 for TE Terrance Ferguson. Dominic dropped Brissett and added Spears and Aiyuk.
These are early numbers, and Nathaniel B. is projected 105.11 only because his lineup is not set. He scored 169.18 last week.
Read the breakdown
Sleeper's early numbers have Aayush at 123.36 and Nathaniel B. at 105.11, a 65% to 35% edge. Nathaniel B. is 5-3 on a 169.18 game with Joe Burrow at 52.48, but has scored 122.5 a game and is outside the playoff field. Aayush scored 83.20 with Breece Hall out and Jake Ferguson hurt in the first half, but he scored 160.88 a week before and holds the last playoff spot on points. Nathaniel B. dropped Kendrick Bourne for Adonai Mitchell.
Michael is 5-3 and third in points, and he was the favorite before the trade took 9.53 points off his projection. Getting 5 points with a team that scored 160.64 earlier this month is the lean, but he has lost three straight, so it is thin.
Read the breakdown
Sleeper has Michael at 127.93 and Damon at 133.02. Michael sent Kenneth Walker III and Emmett Johnson to Dominic for Bhayshul Tuten and Josh Jacobs, and his projection fell from 137.46. He has lost three straight, scoring 160.64, 80.28 and 94.20, and added Dylan Sampson for $163 after Jeremiyah Love left with a new ankle injury. Damon scored 130.96 to beat Nick, with Tony Pollard at 28.70 and Puka Nacua at 25.00, and left Tyler Allgeier (36.10) on his bench. He added Gardner Minshew II and the Buccaneers defense and dropped J.K. Dobbins. Damon is 2-6 and has won two of his last three.
Matthew is 7-1 and first in points, and a field-goal spread is cheap for him. The risk is the empty quarterback spot with Lamar Jackson out.
Read the breakdown
The closest game on the board by a projection: Sleeper has Matthew at 151.20 and Tommy at 148.23. Matthew is 7-1 and won in Week 8 by 10.32 with 0.00 from Lamar Jackson, whose thumb injury is potentially season-ending, and Kirk Cousins (34.18 on his bench) is the obvious replacement. Tommy scored 143.56 and has won two in a row. This is also a points-race game, since Tommy is the fifth seed on points.
Dalton is 5-3 and has allowed the second-fewest points in the league (995.26). Getting 4 points on the better record is the value.
Read the breakdown
Sleeper has Nick at 132.39 and Dalton at 128.47. Nick is 3-5, the sixth seed by 0.30 points over Aayush, and has lost two straight after scoring 113.78 against Damon. Dalton is 5-3 and has lost two in a row, 113.72 to Aayush and 127.88 to Matthew, but has allowed the second-fewest points in the league (995.26). The record and the points allowed favor Dalton.
Chris's 98.51 is an early projection with an unset lineup, so 27.5 points is too many.
Read the breakdown
Sleeper's early numbers had Alex at 125.94 and Chris at 98.51, a 72% to 28% edge, but Chris's lineup is not set, so that number will move. Alex scored 120.86 to beat Michael, with Josh Allen at 31.56, and added Chimere Dike for $55 and Chris Rodriguez Jr. for $31. Chris scored 103.38 against Dominic, 43.40 of it from Moore and Wilson, who came in the trade, and has the fewest points in the league (881.08).
These lines come straight from Sleeper: the spread is the gap between the two Week 9 projections rounded to the half point, the moneyline comes from Sleeper's win probability (except in Dominic vs. Dylan and Michael vs. Damon, where the Chronicle estimated it from the new gaps), and the total is the two projections added together. Chris, Nathaniel B. and Aayush are on early numbers because their lineups are not set, so those lines will move. The picks are the Chronicle's read against the line. Lines are for fun only.
| MANAGER | DATE | ADDED | DROPPED | FAAB |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nathaniel B. | Nov 4 | Adonai Mitchell (WR, NYJ) | Kendrick Bourne (WR, ARI) | $175 |
| Michael | Nov 4 | Dylan Sampson (RB, CLE) | Ted Hurst III (WR, TB) | $163 |
| Tommy | Nov 4 | Mike Gesicki (TE, CIN) | Kalif Raymond (WR, CHI) | $90 |
| Alex | Nov 4 | Chimere Dike (WR, TEN) | — | $55 |
| Dylan | Nov 4 | Terrance Ferguson (TE, LAR) | — | $35 |
| Alex | Nov 4 | Chris Rodriguez Jr. (RB, JAX) | — | $31 |
| Matthew | Nov 4 | Texans DEF | Commanders DEF | $12 |
| Damon | Nov 4 | Buccaneers DEF | Bengals DEF | $5 |
| Dominic | Nov 4 | Tyjae Spears (RB, TEN) | — | $2 |
| Dominic | Nov 4 | Reggie Virgil (WR, ARI) | — | $2 |
| Michael | Nov 4 | Tyler Bass (K, BUF) | Chad Ryland (K, ARI) | $0 |
| Dominic | Nov 4 | Brandon Aiyuk (WR, SF) | Reggie Virgil (WR, ARI) | — |
| Dominic | Nov 4 | Chiefs DEF | — | — |
| Damon | Nov 4 | Gardner Minshew II (QB, ARI) | — | — |
| Michael | Nov 4 | — | Elic Ayomanor (WR, TEN) | — |
| Damon | Nov 3 | — | J.K. Dobbins (RB, DEN) | — |
| Dylan | Nov 3 | — | Tyreek Hill (WR) | — |
| Dominic | Nov 3 | — | Jacoby Brissett (QB), Bears DEF, Chig Okonkwo (TE) | — |